45 acres with a creek for sale in Tay, ON

$469,900 · Tay, Simcoe County, Ontario · 11 km from Midland

Advertised on Kijiji as “5493 MCMANN SIDE ROAD Tay, Ontario”

$469,900Asking price

45Acres

$10,442/acPrice per acre

Creek throughWater

below marketAcreScout value check

67% below the median $31,707/ac for the 74 lots of similar size in Simcoe County.
AcreScout's value model, which compares it with the nearest listings of similar size, rates it below market.
No risk flags found in what we check (flood zones, wetland, access, taxes).
Listed September 6, 2026.

See this listing on the map with its value score, risk details and the all-in cost for your buyer profile. Open in AcreScout Listing on Kijiji

Similar-sized land in Simcoe County

Listing	Price	Acres	Per acre	Value
44 acres Severn	$450,000	44	$10,236/ac	below market
46 acres Barrie	$1,274,777	46	$27,713/ac	near market
47 acres Barrie	$1,465,000	47	$31,170/ac	near market
44 acres Oro Medonte	$1,539,900	44	$34,938/ac	near market
45 acres Oro-Medonte	$2,100,000	45	$46,667/ac	above market
44 acres Tiny	$2,599,900	44	$59,089/ac	above market
46 acres Oakville / Halton Region	$5,999,000	46	$130,413/ac	above market
48 acres Barrie	$8,900,000	48	$186,739/ac	above market